Roof replacement through insurance: Am I being scammed?

  • This topic has 10 replies, 14 voices, and was last updated 2 weeks ago by PM_ME_YOUR_PESKY_ERRORS.
Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 14 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • internal_combustion
    Participant

    I recently had a roofer approach me after a hailstorm, saying many of my neighbors are getting their roofs replaced by insurance. My roof is old, around 15 years, and has some minor damage. This roofer claims they work with my insurance company and can get my entire roof replaced, with me only paying the deductible. This sounds too good to be true, and I’m worried I might be getting involved in a scam. Has anyone else experienced this?

    noisily_draconian_damsel
    Participant

    I’ve learned to be very wary of roofers who go door-to-door after storms. In my area, after a big hail storm, I had three companies not even located near me trying to sell me a new roof. This made me realize the importance of choosing a local company that has been around for a while to avoid potential scams.

    spooky_motto
    Participant

    From my own experience with three insurance claims in five years, I would advise you to never tell the contractor it’s an insurance job right away. I’ve found that this keeps their initial pricing more honest because they don’t assume they can inflate the cost and get it covered by the insurance company.

    tanrepertoire255
    Participant

    As someone who owns a roofing firm and has personally gotten close to 200 roofs fully approved through insurance, I can tell you it’s not always a scam. Many reputable roofing companies do go door-to-door after storms because it’s often the only way to inform homeowners that their property might have damage covered by their insurance. The benefit of the doubt often goes to the homeowner when it comes to storm damage.

    wobblycalamity
    Participant

    I recently went through this, and my insurance gave me full reimbursement, even for depreciation, but held back 25% of the funds until the work was done and I showed proof of cost. So, while they initially gave me roughly $8k of a $12k claim, I needed to submit an invoice to get the remaining $3k.

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 14 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.